This comment by Rose Welsh on that site I recommended all to ignore (I think “discount” would have been a better word) has been bothering me all week and I have yet found a way to address this comment in a context which is constructive and not in any way self-serving.
Here is what she said on a recent post by John Chiv letting us all know …wait for it… that the Arcata Police continue an investigation into a recent murder.
Here is where we all agree with Rose…
a) We want the killer (or murderer) of David Josiah Lawson to come to justice within our justice system, and
b) we agree, that in the light of the tragic or criminal death of David Josiah Lawson, he is remembered as he was, a bright young college student full of potential.
Rose, thank you for expressing those thoughts because it is important to hear them and it’s important to discuss our shared values.
Having said that…
In your defense of McKinleyville, as non-racist you intentionally used race-infused words. Phrases like “lynch-mobs” or “stringing people up” cannot be used in this country without the context of our post-Civil War society.
For the record Rose, I don’t think you are any more or less of a racist than I am. I think you used these jarring and inappropriate words in an attempt to draw attention to what you see as the reverse-racism inherent in any criticism of Humboldt county justice. Criticism which, in turn, may impede the legal process on which we all depend to find and convict Josiah’s killer.
Isn’t that right? Because that is pretty much the only defense I can imagine, other ones are less defensible and include ignorance and/or racism.
As always, I’m really hoping for some conservative or Republican engagement on this issue because we need your leadership especially on the issue of race and racism. Yes, racism exists everywhere, it exists on the left (Bill Maher) and in the North (Boston/Adam Jones). It also exists in Eureka* and McKinleyville. It’s exactly because of this ubiquity that the great majority of us who are repulsed by racism need to be able to speak out together to condemn racist ideas and punish racist activities that harm others.
What’s up Rose? Why did you chose to use “lynch-mob” and “stringing” people up in the exact same sentence you wished to defend where you live as free of racism? Can any other conservative explain this and/or admit that we have a deep and seemingly intractable problem in this county that we need to address head-on?
Conservatives or John Chiv, while you are at it, would you please address this comment from camelg1. Because this bullshit has to be shunned. If it will be left to the left to do the racism-shaming, the comments can be discounted as partisan or self-interested.
Ms. Welch circa 2010 here.