Charles Blow on “We Can’t Breath”

I participated in and am still unable to write about the 400+ comment thread on the small protest regarding police brutality and race this past weekend on Lost Coast Outpost.  One thing is certain, if LoCO needs to up their readership to meet advertiser’s demands, writing about local race issues is always a sure winner.

Charles Blow, columnist for the NYT has another must-read opinion column on the subject of race and racism in America.  Reading this post helps to put into perspective much of the comment section of that post

“Biases are pervasive, but can also be spectral: moving in and out of consideration with little or no notice, without leaving a trace, even without our own awareness. Sometimes the only way to see bias is in the aggregate, to stop staring so hard at a data point and step back so that you can see the data set. Only then can you detect the trails in the dust. Only then can the data do battle with denial.”

He ends with this…

“In this most trying of moments, black men, supported by the people who understand their plight and feel their pain, are saying to the police culture of America, “We can’t breathe!””

What is so meaningful to us locally, especially those on the left, the poor and working class is that many of us understand that there is something wrong with the police culture of America.  We also understand this culture, and our apparent inability to account for law enforcement’s mistakes in judgments and action can be color blind.  In most parts of the country, race overlaps with poverty.  That is much less evident in Humboldt as, by force, law and design we have excluded other races.  (Btw, less evident, but still evident.)

To me, that LoCO thread is another reminder in how pervasively race and “other” overlaps our thoughts and prevents us from working together to solve problems we may otherwise agree on.  Somehow we on the left have to find a way to ask people to find commonalities and brother (or sister) hood even with those who may look different than they do.  In the end, the reason this is so hard to do is we default to our own tribes when resources (ie in our case – living wage jobs) are scarce.

Therefore, often, the poor and the working classes put their trust in those able to supply jobs and willing to silently confirm their instinct to distrust and segregate from those unlike ourselves.

“Give me enough for my labor to put food on my table and give me someone we can blame and we’ll call it good.”

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Charles Blow on “We Can’t Breath”

  1. Henchman Of Justice says:

    Good post LJ.

    One opinion is that those who really understand being black “are black people telling the truth and facts of what it is TO BE BLACK.” Not white people, brown people, or any other people.

    Also, interracial couples will have better knowledge “together by understanding through the hopefully caring relationship” of what it is to be black and white as part of that union.

    The first quote you italicized was immensely powerful and true, and applies to so many of us. Where as individuals have long and enduring life processes to datafy for cumulative proof to alleviate paranoia concerns and seek justice, so too has race and civil rights issues had to datafy all these years just to prove race discrimination still exists and does in fact create injustices upon black people. The justice system fails so many people no matter what color, which supports the claims of injustices by those who represent justice.

    The higher up law enforcers are not usually boots on the ground. Somewhere lost in the valley lies that great divide that separates job duty and cause and effect situations. Somewhere lost in the valley is the all seeing eye. Somewhere lost in the valley are the overseerers of justice and those who oversee the overseers. Somewhere in the valley those who wield the power and control and authority ceased self discipline and control. Somewhere, the money paid by the abused disappeared into the pockets of the overseers and their overseers, from manipulatively high up in the head all the way down to boot stomping pain.

    How and who exactly determine who serves as a grand juror? Yep, check it out. Is there independent review or is it s.o.s.o. stacking like commissions, committees, boards, etcc.?

    Dirty politics is rife in america but voters turn a blind eye at the ballot booth sadly enough.

    Jeffrey Lytle
    Mck, 5th. District

  2. HOJ! I hope you are well. The humCo intertubes have been much less content for the past few months, Glad to have you back! Nothing much has changed if you haven’t already noticed.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s